clock menu more-arrow no yes

Nine Must-Visit Pie Destinations in Atlanta

View as Map

Moving into the cooler autumn months, it's time to step away from lighter desserts and toward assortments of custard and fruit fillings held together by baked and fried crusts. Yes, pie season is here. Served a la mode, at a big holiday meal, or even for breakfast (we won't judge), there's no wrong way or time to enjoy a slice of pie. And with nearly endless possibilities for flavor profiles, your palate will never get board.

Whether it's a dedicated shop or a restaurant with a particularly noteworthy dessert, these nine Atlanta-area venues, mapped north to south, provide exemplary pies to cap off a meal. So dig in and let the sugar rush wash over you.

Don't see your favorite pie destination represented on this map? Give it some love in the comments or via the tipline.

Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. The Pie Hole

Copy Link
1025 Canton St
Roswell, GA 30075
(678) 461-3776
Visit Website
As if the name isn’t appetizing enough, this rustic pie shop in Roswell rotates inventory with the seasons to complement solid assortment of permanent flavors.

2. Buttermilk Sky

Copy Link
4600 Roswell Rd Ste C130
Sandy Springs, GA 30342
Originally from Knoxville, Tenn., this pie shop offers classic and seasonal options along with a “Cloud 9” option (pie and ice cream mix). Each month, it donates a portion of one pie’s sales to a local charitable organization with “Pie it Forward.”

3. Sugar Shack

Copy Link
4058 Peachtree Rd NE
Brookhaven, GA 30319
(404) 816-6161
Visit Website
Aptly named for its sweet offerings, Sugar Shack dishes out 9-inch to 12-inch pies and 4-inch mini pies. Varieties include standard fruit and pecan along with seasonal pumpkin pies.

4. The Silver Skillet

Copy Link
200 14th St NW
Atlanta, GA 30318
(404) 874-1388
Visit Website
Often mentioned in local and national publications, this old-school restaurant’s lemon icebox pie wraps up condensed milk, egg yolks, and lemon juice in a graham cracker and vanilla wafer crust.

5. The Optimist

Copy Link
914 Howell Mill Rd NW
Atlanta, GA 30318
(404) 477-6260
Visit Website
Ford Fry’s Westside establishment is known for its seafood, but the fried peach pie stuffs locally sourced fruit into a cinnamon-sugar tossed, deep-fried mini pie.

6. Mary Mac's Tea Room

Copy Link
224 Ponce de Leon Ave NE
Atlanta, GA 30308
(404) 876-1800
Visit Website
Atlanta’s poster child for Southern comfort is known for its heaping helpings and wide variety of regional dishes, including the Key lime, pecan, and peanut butter pies.

7. Revival

Copy Link
129 Church St
Decatur, GA 30030
At Top Chef alum Kevin Gillespie's shrine to traditional Southern fare, excellent pies obviously have a spot on the dessert menu. Revival serves peanut butter-Oreo and lemon icebox varieties.

8. Fox Bros. Bar-B-Q

Copy Link
1238 Dekalb Ave NE
Atlanta, GA 30307
(404) 577-4030
Visit Website
You might fill up on delectable meats at this Candler Park smokehouse, but try to save room for dessert. The chocolate chip-studded pecan pie is a winner.

9. Panbury's Double Crust Pies

Copy Link
209 Edgewood Ave SE Ste 104
Atlanta, GA 30303
(404) 500-1279
Visit Website
Located inside Sweet Auburn Curb Market, Panbury’s pies represent comfort food in its purest form. The offerings are savory and filling with heartier steak options and sweeter standards such as apple or peach.

1. The Pie Hole

1025 Canton St, Roswell, GA 30075
As if the name isn’t appetizing enough, this rustic pie shop in Roswell rotates inventory with the seasons to complement solid assortment of permanent flavors.
1025 Canton St
Roswell, GA 30075

2. Buttermilk Sky

4600 Roswell Rd Ste C130, Sandy Springs, GA 30342
Originally from Knoxville, Tenn., this pie shop offers classic and seasonal options along with a “Cloud 9” option (pie and ice cream mix). Each month, it donates a portion of one pie’s sales to a local charitable organization with “Pie it Forward.”
4600 Roswell Rd Ste C130
Sandy Springs, GA 30342

3. Sugar Shack

4058 Peachtree Rd NE, Brookhaven, GA 30319
Aptly named for its sweet offerings, Sugar Shack dishes out 9-inch to 12-inch pies and 4-inch mini pies. Varieties include standard fruit and pecan along with seasonal pumpkin pies.
4058 Peachtree Rd NE
Brookhaven, GA 30319

4. The Silver Skillet

200 14th St NW, Atlanta, GA 30318
Often mentioned in local and national publications, this old-school restaurant’s lemon icebox pie wraps up condensed milk, egg yolks, and lemon juice in a graham cracker and vanilla wafer crust.
200 14th St NW
Atlanta, GA 30318

5. The Optimist

914 Howell Mill Rd NW, Atlanta, GA 30318
Ford Fry’s Westside establishment is known for its seafood, but the fried peach pie stuffs locally sourced fruit into a cinnamon-sugar tossed, deep-fried mini pie.
914 Howell Mill Rd NW
Atlanta, GA 30318

6. Mary Mac's Tea Room

224 Ponce de Leon Ave NE, Atlanta, GA 30308
Atlanta’s poster child for Southern comfort is known for its heaping helpings and wide variety of regional dishes, including the Key lime, pecan, and peanut butter pies.
224 Ponce de Leon Ave NE
Atlanta, GA 30308

7. Revival

129 Church St, Decatur, GA 30030
At Top Chef alum Kevin Gillespie's shrine to traditional Southern fare, excellent pies obviously have a spot on the dessert menu. Revival serves peanut butter-Oreo and lemon icebox varieties.
129 Church St
Decatur, GA 30030

8. Fox Bros. Bar-B-Q

1238 Dekalb Ave NE, Atlanta, GA 30307
You might fill up on delectable meats at this Candler Park smokehouse, but try to save room for dessert. The chocolate chip-studded pecan pie is a winner.
1238 Dekalb Ave NE
Atlanta, GA 30307

9. Panbury's Double Crust Pies

209 Edgewood Ave SE Ste 104, Atlanta, GA 30303
Located inside Sweet Auburn Curb Market, Panbury’s pies represent comfort food in its purest form. The offerings are savory and filling with heartier steak options and sweeter standards such as apple or peach.
209 Edgewood Ave SE Ste 104
Atlanta, GA 30303

Related Maps